The real cost of non-compliance: what letting agents can't afford to ignore

Compliance in the UK lettings sector is often treated as a box-ticking exercise. Gas Safety Certificates, EPCs, and Deposit Protection Schemes are the well-known essentials that every agent expects to manage, but the real risks don’t always come with a checklist. Oversights can lead to crippling fines, legal battles, and reputational damage, with the biggest threats often lurking in grey areas of legislation, quiet regulatory changes, and obligations that only become clear when something goes wrong.

Inventory base logo

Hidden dangers

Think of compliance as an iceberg. Above the surface, the obvious obligations - safety checks, deposit protections, licensing rules; all seem straightforward enough. But beneath the water line lurks a tangled web of lesser-known responsibilities, each carrying its own risks.

The fallout isn’t limited to fines. Operational strain, reputational damage, and legal exposure can disrupt an entire business. Letting agents who don’t stay ahead of compliance don’t only risk financial penalties - they risk losing trust, clients, and the ability to trade.

The true price of failure

What that hidden risk landscape really looks like.

Compliance Area
The Risk
Potential Cost
GDPR and data protection Requires audits, breach protocols, and-third party agreements Fines up to £17.5 million or 4% of turnover; legal claims
AML regulations (from May 2025) Letting agents must report suspected sanctioned clients to OFSI Unlimited fines; criminal charges
Fire risk assessments Applies to all non-domestic/common areas, not just HMOs Fines from £5,000 to unlimited; criminal liability
Electrical safety Ongoing checks beyond the 5-year EICR often neglected Fines up to £30,000
Legionella risk assessments  Mandatory even for single-occupancy properties Unlimited fines if an outbreak occurs
ICO registration Required for agents processing personal data Fines from £4,000, higher if left unpaid
Right to Rent checks Failure to verify tenant eligibility Fines up to £20,000 per tenant; criminal prosecution
Smoke and CO alarms  Must check alarms at tenancy start Fines up to £5,000 per property; liability for harm
Consumer protection regulations Misleading property descriptions, even if accidental Uncapped fines; legal action
Property licensing  Local councils introduce schemes with little notice Fines up to £30,000; rent repayment orders
Building Safety Act 2022 Applies to high-risk buildings over 18m or 7 stories. Requires accountable persons and safety case reports Fines up to £10 million; criminal charges
Material Information Agents must provide key details upfront Fines and legal action from Trading Standards
Minimum EPC standards  Properties must meet EPC E now, and C by 2028 Fines up to £5,000 (domestic) or £150,000 (commercial)
HMO planning permissions (Article 4) Some councils require planning consent for HMOs, even without a license requirement Fines; enforcement notices; property devaluation
Furniture and furnishings (fire safety) Rented furniture must meet fire resistance standards Fines up to £5,000 per item; liability for tenant harm
Deposit protection Deposits must be registered within 30 days, with prescribed information Fines up to 3x the deposit amount per breach 
Fitness for Human Habitation Act 2018  Tenants can sue if property is unfit Compensation claims; unlimited fines
Defective Premises Act 1972 (Amended 2022) Landlords can be sued for negligence causing harm Unlimited damages claims
Section 21 and 8 Reform (pending Renters' Rights Bill) Changes may impact eviction rights and notice periods Legal fees; lost rental income
Japanese knotweed and other invasive species Landlords must prevent the spread of invasive plants Fines of up to £5,000; ASBOs for breaches
Stamp Duty Land Tax and ATED Applies if properties are company-owned or exceed thresholds Tax liabilities; penalties for non-disclosure

Fines are not the only cost

It’s easy to think of compliance failures in terms of financial penalties, but the bigger impact is often operational disruption, legal battles, and reputational damage.

A single dispute over a missing safety check can lead to a lengthy legal case. A compliance breach can mean weeks of stress, paperwork, and lost time. A data protection failure can trigger an investigation that affects every client an agency has.

Then there’s the damage to a company’s brand in an industry where trust is everything. A single mistake can follow a business for years, making it harder to attract landlords, renew contracts, or expand.

Protecting a business and its reputation

Compliance isn’t something to fix after the fact; it should be woven into day-to-day operations. That means tight systems, clear processes, and the right technology to ensure every bit of data is connected so that nothing slips through the cracks.

Rather than seeing compliance as an administrative burden, recognise it for what it really is: a business safeguard. It protects clients, employees, and the long-term profitability of a business.

Being proactive isn’t about avoiding fines, it’s about staying ahead of the game, bringing lesser-known compliance risks above the waterline and into plain sight.

Inventory base logo
InventoryBase: Property inspection software

Our multi-award winning software has been designed to work with the residential and lettings market and built to provide Propertymark members with intuitive and responsive property reporting options across all systems and devices.